BuryYourDuke wrote:It's all an argument without proof, that's what makes college football so interesting. However, I would argue that Alabama, LSU, and South Carolina were better teams than Auburn. Remember that it took a literal miracle for Auburn to get by a Georgia team with most of its starters out. Auburn had literally the luckiest run in the history of college football.
Like I said, Florida State ran the table, played a great second half last night and deserves the crystal ball. However, just like in the regular season, they benefited from their schedule in the post season as well.
The SEC dominance will continue, anybody who believes otherwise is living in a dream world.
Find me a team in recent memory who didn't have some measure of luck during their run and I'll chalk one up to you.
LSU for once had a solid offense led by Mettenberger and they did get the win against Auburn, though it was at home in one of the most hostile stadiums in all of college football. Had LSU's defense been as good as the past 8 years, I'd probably buy your argument for them. I can't though... they were too inconsistent and made too many mental mistakes against weaker opponents (ie Ole Miss). They finished out their year with a mediocre win against Iowa.
South Carolina had similar issues to LSU relating to consistency. They had two solid wins against Mizzou and Clemson, but they lost to a UT team that finished 5-7 on the year and they BARELY beat Florida, who was awful this year. I'm really surprised you thought they were better than Auburn.
I'll let the Alabama comment live on as I agree that Alabama probably has more talent on their team. But Malzahn had his guys ready to go and in the end the dice rolled their way in what was one of the most epic finishes to a game ever. Sure it might have been "lucky", but they played hard that night and put themselves in a situation to capitalize on the situation to end the game.
And I'll agree with you... FSU played an easier schedule. But they dominated the schedule nonetheless. Their smallest margin of victory was 14 pts... They dismantled a high-flying Clemson team in Clemson, SC and they destroyed Duke in the ACC Championship game. And before you say anything about the Duke mention, remember what Duke did to Texas A&M in that bowl game. Duke turned heads this season, and without the heroics of Johnny Manziel - they win that game easily. I think we can expect the SEC to win a few of the new era championships, but it seems that the ACC is finally getting its football act together. Clemson is a real threat (impressive win against UGA), FSU is already there, Miami is making a comeback along with UNC (as long as they avoid sanctions in the future) and there is always a wildcard team in the mix (VT, Duke, Pitt, and next season Louisville). So you can expect plenty of competition and wins from the ACC in the future vs. SEC teams.