[bradyfan]

Saw a discussion about preseason top 25 polls. I thought it would be cool if we came up with our own poll.

Here's mine:

1. Appalachian State
2. Georgia Southern
3. Montana State
4. William & Mary
5. New Hampshire
6. Wofford
7. Lehigh
8. Delaware
9. E. Washington
10. Northern Iowa
11. Richmond
12. Montana
13. Villanova
14. Stephen F. Austin
15. Liberty
16. Southern Illinois
17. Jacksonville St.
18. North Dakota St.
19. Central Arkansas
20. McNeese St.
21. JMU
22. UMass
23. Chattanooga
24. E. Kentucky
25. Sacramento St.

Once a few more people post some, I'll make a consolidated one. We can call it the Flamesfans poll! haha.

[jcmanson]

I love your enthusiasm, but I'm not sure how many of us follow FCS enough to put together a poll, particularly in the preseason. May be a good idea to do it once the season starts.

[bradyfan]

I love your enthusiasm, but I'm not sure how many of us follow FCS enough to put together a poll, particularly in the preseason. May be a good idea to do it once the season starts.

That's unfortunate, I might follow it a little too close. haha.

[jcmanson]

Don't apologize. The more informed posters we have on here, the better.

I could throw a poll together, but it wouldn't be worth the paper it's printed on. After 2 or 3 weeks of play, I could put together a decent poll, as well could many others on here.

[BJWilliams]

This is the one I submitted for another message board:

1: Eastern Washington Eagles
2: Appalachian State Mountaineers
3: Georgia Southern Eagles
4: Delaware Fightin' Blue Hens
5: Montana Grizzlies
6: William & Mary Tribe
7: North Dakota State Bison
8: Montana State Bobcats
9: Stephen F. Austin Lumberjacks
10: Wofford Terriers
11: South Carolina State Bulldogs
12: Lehigh Mountain Hawks
13: James Madison Dukes
14: Liberty Flames
15: Northern Iowa Panthers
16: Jacksonville State Gamecocks
17: UMass Minutemen
18: Furman Paladins
19: Penn Quakers
20: Bethune-Cookman Wildcats
21: Southeast Missouri State Redhawks
22: Cal Poly Mustangs
23: Western Illinois Leathernecks
24: Jacksonville Dolphins
25: Chattanooga Mocs

[NG33]

These things are always a crapshoot, but I'll give it a go:

1. Eastern Washington
2. Georgia Southern
3. App. State
4. Montana State
5. Delaware
6. Northern Iowa
7. William & Mary
8. Wofford
9. Jacksonville State
10. New Hampshire
11. Montana
12. North Dakota State
13. Central Arkansas
14. Stephen F. Austin
15. Cal Poly
16. Lehigh
17. Chattanooga
18. James Madison
19. Southern Illinois
20. Liberty
21. Sacramento State
22. McNeese State
23. Southern Missouri State
24. Stony Brook
25. Murray State

[Cider Jim]

Can't we find a homer to put us in the top 10? Where's Rooster when you need him?

[Old School]

I'm a homer, so here we go......

1 EASTERN WASHINGTON
2 GEORGIA SOUTHERN
3 APPALACHIAN STATE
4 MONTANA STATE
5 DELAWARE
6 WOFFORD
7 NORTHERN IOWA
8 JACKSONVILLE STATE
9 WILLIAM AND MARY
10 LIBERTY
11 LEHIGH
12 MONTANA
13 CAL POLY
14 NEW HAMPSHIRE
15 NORTH DAKOTA STATE
16 CENTRAL ARKANSAS
17 STEPHEN F. AUSTIN
18 RICHMOND
19 JAMES MADISON
20 STONY BROOK
21 MURRAY STATE
22 MCNEESE STATE
23 SOUTHERN MISSOURI STATE
24 SOUTHERN ILLINOIS
25 CHATTANOOGA

[Rooster Cogburn]

The real homer is here

1 EASTERN WASHINGTON
2 GEORGIA SOUTHERN
3 DELAWARE
4 APPALACHIAN STATE
5 MONTANA STATE
6 WOFFORD
7 NORTHERN IOWA
8 LIBERTY
9 WILLIAM AND MARY
10 LEHIGH
11 Jacksonville St.
12 MONTANA
13 CAL POLY
14 NEW HAMPSHIRE
15 NORTH DAKOTA STATE
16 RICHMOND
17 CENTRAL ARKANSAS
18 JAMES MADISON
19 STEPHEN F. AUSTIN
20 STONY BROOK
21 MURRAY STATE
22 MCNEESE STATE
23 SOUTHERN MISSOURI STATE
24 SOUTHERN ILLINOIS
25 CHATTANOOGA

[bradyfan]

Here's the consolidated poll for now...

1. Eastern Washington (4)
2. Georgia Southern
3. Appalachian State (1)
4. Montana State
5. Deleware
6. Wofford
7. William & Mary
8. Norhtern Iowa
9. Montana
10. Lehigh
11. Jacksonville St.
12. New Hampshire
13. (T) Liberty
13. (T) North Dakota St.
15. Stephen F. Austin
16. JMU
17. Cal Poly
18. Central Arkansas
19. Richmond
20. Southern Illinois
21. McNeese St.
22. (T) Chattanooga
22. (T) South Carolina St.
24. (T) South East Missori St.
24. (T) Stony Brook

Others receiving votes: Villanova, Umass, E. Kentucky, Sacramento St., Furman, Penn, Bethune-Cookman, Western Illinois, Jacksonville, Murray State

[Flamesfan4ever]

1. Liberty University
2. Eastern Washington
3. App. State
4. Delaware
5. Montana
6. William a& Mary
7. Georgia Southern
8. Wofford
9. Lehigh
10. Richmond
11 Cal POly
12. N. Dakota St.
13. Jacksonville St.
14. New Hampshire
15. Central Arkansas
16. JMU
17. Stephen F. Austin
18. Stony Brook
19. Murray State
20. S. Illionois
21. Chatanooga
22. Sacramento State
23. McNeese St.
24. Umass
25. Sparky

[jbock13]

1. Liberty University

Was waiting to see who would be the first person to do this

[BJWilliams]

1. Liberty University
2. Eastern Washington
3. App. State
4. Delaware
5. Montana
6. William a& Mary
7. Georgia Southern
8. Wofford
9. Lehigh
10. Richmond
11 Cal POly
12. N. Dakota St.
13. Jacksonville St.
14. New Hampshire
15. Central Arkansas
16. JMU
17. Stephen F. Austin
18. Stony Brook
19. Murray State
20. S. Illionois
21. Chatanooga
22. Sacramento State
23. McNeese St.
24. Umass
25. Sparky

Now THIS^^^ is a homer!

[bradyfan]

1. Liberty University
2. Eastern Washington
3. App. State
4. Delaware
5. Montana
6. William a& Mary
7. Georgia Southern
8. Wofford
9. Lehigh
10. Richmond
11 Cal POly
12. N. Dakota St.
13. Jacksonville St.
14. New Hampshire
15. Central Arkansas
16. JMU
17. Stephen F. Austin
18. Stony Brook
19. Murray State
20. S. Illionois
21. Chatanooga
22. Sacramento State
23. McNeese St.
24. Umass
25. Sparky

120. Coastal

[jbock13]

120. Coastal

I was also about to do this

[Cider Jim]

Who/What/Where is Sparky?

[jcmanson]

Who/What/Where is Sparky?

[Cider Jim]

Why is our mascot ranked #25?

[flamehunter]

Why is our mascot ranked #25?

Exactly!! He is at least top 15, I'd probably put him around 8-9.

[Flamesfan4ever]

No....he is sort of like Ayers at Cornerback and has not proven himself yet. If he proves capable ....I will raise Sparky up to 8 or 9 in the polls and lower Jacksonville State to sit over on the bench with Kajuan Lee !!!

[jcmanson]

bump

This is my top 25 for this week:
1. Georgia Southern 3-0
2. North Dakota State 3-1
3. Northern Iowa 2-1
4. Montana State 2-1
5. New Hampshire 2-1
6. JMU 3-1
7. App State 3-1
8. Lehigh 3-1
9. Richmond 3-1
10. Sam Houston St 3-0
11. Delaware 3-1
12. Wofford 2-1
13. William & Mary 2-2
14. Sac State 2-2
15. Chattanooga 2-2
16. Jacksonville State 3-1
17. Southern Utah 3-1
18. Montana 2-2
19. Southern Illinois 2-1
20. Towson 3-0
21. SC State 2-2
22. Indiana State 3-1
23. UMass 2-1
24. South Dakota 2-2
25. UT Martin 2-1

[Chris Lang]

My only argument is you having Sac State over Southern Utah. SUU pounded Sac State and is a missed two-point conversion away from being 4-0, with a blowout win over UNLV on the resume.

[Sly Fox]

And perhaps because I am closer to the situation, I have to wonder what Sam needs to do to be ahead of Lehigh & Richmond. Sam's resume thus far is better than about half of the top ten. And you could argue that playing inthe Southland they have an easier path to have a good record at end of season than that glut of CAA squads.

[jcmanson]

Yeah, I had a really hard time placing Sac State. They’ve got 2 good wins and 2 head scratching losses. I almost switched SUU & Sac State at 17 and 14.

As for SHSU, I am really impressed with what they’ve done. You could definitely make a case for them to be top 5.