Cider Jim wrote:PAmedic wrote:the debate, I suppose, is: is a crappy DI opponent better/worse for us than a good DII team?
Not really a debate at all, Medic. My understanding is that when it comes to the playoff selection committee, any DII wins don't count as wins at all, from their perspective.
It's always better to play a DI cupcake than a DII powerhouse (and if I'm wrong, Super will correct me sometime after breakfast). 
This is what I agree with. Better to have beaten a very bad DI that the committee will look at, than a DII that the committee will ignore. If you beat the DII national champ, and that DII national champ also beats Coastal, the committee doesn't give a rip. Beat a bottom feeder like Valpo, St Francis, Indiana State, or Savannah State, and you've got yourself a resume builder.
It was my privilege to serve you today. If you have any feedback, please direct it to my Assistant Director....