If roundball is your blood, this is the place to discuss the Flames as they move into the Ritchie McKay era for the 2nd time.

Moderators: jcmanson, Sly Fox, BuryYourDuke

By SuperJon
Registration Days Posts
#125189
Let me first say that I have complete faith in Jeff, Mickey, Kevin, and whoever else is involved in this that the right thing will be done, but I want your opinion on this.

We have talked about people getting on our cases for yelling things in the stands before, and I wanted to have one thread about it because it all came to a head tonight at the Barton game. I'm going to explain what happened and try to be as objective as I can. This will probably be a little long, but please read it and give your opinion. Keep things civil. I want a discussion, not a fight.

About a minute and a half into the game tonight, I was threatened to get kicked out by an LUPD officer. Barton's coach was on the floor yelling at the ref and I yelled at him and said, "Sit down and shutup." As I was turned talking to someone else, an LUPD officer came and grabbed my arm and spun me around. Apparently he had tried getting my attention but I didn't hear him, so he grabbed me. He told me if I said shutup again I was going to be removed from the game.

After this situation, I went and found Jeff Barber. I apologized for bothering him while he was with his family, told him what happened, and he said it was the first time he'd heard about it. I asked him if saying shutup was ok and he told me it was. I told him I wasn't cussing and wouldn't do that, he understood, and I went back to my seat. A little while later Mickey walked up to me and asked what happened, I explained, and was told as long as it wasn't cussing or sexual in nature that it was fine. I said ok, and went back about my way.

Later in the second half, I yelled at the coach to shutup again. The LUPD officer just looked ticked off but he didn't say anything. Just because I'm an antagonizing jerk sometimes (I admit it), when one of their players was leaving the court we yelled, "Sit down! Shut up!" when he went to the bench. This brought another LUPD officer to us. He was telling me I couldn't say that. I was pointing out that I was told I could by two people, and was talking with my hands, and since I was higher up than he was, he felt as though I was putting them in his face (understandable looking back on it). He told me to stop being disrespectful to him and I told them to stop being a prick to me and grabbing me, etc (I later apologized to him and the other officer but we'll get to that in a minute). He relayed that to Kevin Keys and Kevin said something to me about it, and I apologized to Kevin and admitted I lost my cool for a second.

After the game, the original officer came up to me and we started talking. Nothing rude, just a conversation. He was explaining why he told me I couldn't say shutup. Apparently Ron Godwin and Dwayne Carson said we shouldn't say it. He was an older man, and I told him I believed it was a generation thing because shutup is not offensive to us and may be to his generation. We talked about that for a few second. After that, I told him that Jeff and Mickey told me I could say it, and until they say otherwise, I will. I also said that last year they asked us not to say the word "suck" and we have obeyed that request for the most part (it slips at times). During this conversation, a woman from Barton came up and questioned if I was a Christian or not because I was saying shutup during the game. She questioned what the faith meant on my shirt.

During this whole conversation, Kevin Keys was within ear distance and was listening. He later chimed in and said something along the lines of if we did what every school thought we should do as Christians, we'd be sitting on our hands the entire time. Presby fans complained and said we were rude because our students stood the whole time and waved pom poms. Coastal fans complained because we stood and used thunder sticks and were loud. Some of our fans thought that "Beat Coastal" was degrading to Coastal and we shouldn't do things that could be degrading to the other team.

As the conversation went on, I apologized to the older LUPD officer for what I said (the prick statement), I explained that I lost my cool and apologized for that, and was sincere about the whole thing. I shook his hand, we both said that we wouldn't hold a grudge, etc. As I saw the younger one leaving, I got his attention, apologized to him personally, shook his hand, and we all ended by telling each other to have a good night.

The whole thing boiled down to the fact that the Athletic Department and I guess it's Spiritual Life/Student Affairs will have to have a talk about what can and cannot be said at game. What we think doesn't really matter in the grand scheme of things, but I want to know where we draw the line. What is too much? Where is the line? "You suck" is obviously over it. Is yelling at a coach to shutup over the line or is it ok? What is acceptable and what isn't?

Once again, I ask to please keep this civil and a discussion, not a fight. I want to be serious about this one.
User avatar
By ToTheLeft
Registration Days Posts
#125194
I don't even think "You suck" is over the line.

There are things considered generally obscene.

"F*** you coach, sit down" is a no-brainer.

"Coach, you suck, shut up." is not quite a no brainer.

To me, that's just saying "Stop whining, our team is winning, you are bugging me by being so loud, and I wanna rub it in your face, in this competitive atmosphere."

But I will from here on out, concede "that sucks", since it is a moot argument.

As for shut-up, there is no sexual undertones, no euphemism of any profane word, it is just a more emotional, emphatic version of be quiet.

I don't see any reason why a Christian shouldn't say the word, there is nothing unwholesome about it in a competitive situation. We don't really think poorly of that coach, we don't know him. He was whining about our team, we said shut up.

No big deal in my book.

Now, after the game, going up to the coach and saying "You need to shut up, I am sick of your crap" is totally different. It is personal, and an attack. In the spirit of a game, it's just somethign we say to get behind our team. It isn't something wrong that we are making right, it is something that isn't wrong, that, when used out of anger, becomes wrong.
User avatar
By flameshaw
Registration Days Posts
#125198
You should have told the LUPD to sit down and shut up. :D Sorry, I have a hard time being serious about this one. If they want to go so far as say you can't say something like "shut up" they might as well start making students wear ties to games and carry a Bible under your arm for admission to the games, pretty silly really. A ball game is one thing, church/school is quite another.
User avatar
By Sly Fox
Registration Days Posts
#125203
Wow, that's some heavy reading. I'm glad this is coming to a head BEFORE the season starts.

I think it is possible to be passionate while still maintaining a testimony. Jesus himself managed to pull off both things throughout his time on earth.

Personally I see the solution being a bit of creativity. Telling a coach to shut up is lame & ineffective IMHO. Enterprising young minds that can pull off pranks that are months in the making should be able to come up with more intuitive verbal jabs that deliver the same punch with a twist. :wink:
User avatar
By El Scorcho
Registration Days Posts
#125205
I'm going to sit this one out for a while just to see where it goes, but I do want to say this...

After the game was over I walked to the other side of the Vines just to say hello to SJ and his crew, because I thought they did a great job at the game. I walked up just as all of this was starting, so I sat down at the end of the row closest to them and watched. At some point I got a little closer so I could hear what Kevin Keys was saying, which is when the Barton woman showed up. Anyway, everything SJ said is exactly how I remember it. He's not exaggerating or making a big deal over nothing. LUPD was all up in his biz, and the Barton lady did actually question his salvation because of the game.

With that, I'll leave you folks to discuss.
User avatar
By whmatthews
Registration Days Posts
#125206
If I had a nickel for every time I went through that same experience SJ, I could pay off my student loans. I've been to Winthrop three times for a game and VMI twice - Liberty is rated PG compared to some of those crowds. Last season when we started sitting in the corner opposite of Bakers Bunch for the Killer B's, Dwayne Carson sat beside us many games and yelled "Shut up" and "Suck" more than we were, honestly. So, if it was anyone from Spiritual Life/Campus Pastors Office saying we can't say something that the Athletic Department says we can, they definitely need to get on the same page. My gut feeling is that if they do have a sit down about what's acceptable heckling, the Spiritual Life would probably win, unfortunately.
User avatar
By whmatthews
Registration Days Posts
#125207
Sly Fox wrote:Wow, that's some heavy reading. I'm glad this is coming to a head BEFORE the season starts.

I think it is possible to be passionate while still maintaining a testimony. Jesus himself managed to pull off both things throughout his time on earth.

Personally I see the solution being a bit of creativity. Telling a coach to shut up is lame & ineffective IMHO. Enterprising young minds that can pull off pranks that are months in the making should be able to come up with more intuitive verbal jabs that deliver the same punch with a twist. :wink:
True, but sometimes a good shut up or you suck just comes out naturally, and sometimes things are so fast-paced, you just gotta get something, anything out!
User avatar
By Iwasneverhere
Registration Days Posts
#125209
That would only work if we were playing an opponent that happens to be on on the same intellectual playing field as we are.
some how i don't think many college basketball players (or coaches)have the mental capacity to understand verbal jabber other than shut up. i mean come on. what am i going to say..." Pardon me Coach, you need to silence your orifice!" ? i mean seriously people. get over the stupid generation gap and enjoy the dang game.
By SuperJon
Registration Days Posts
#125222
My question is what is too far? I don't understand it. To me, chanting "You can't do that" or "Step step step step sit down" is just as offensive as, "Hey, shutup." I'm known for finding dirt on players such as their girlfriends' names, siblings' names, etc, and everyone says that's funny. How is that not offensive and "Shutup" is? People laughed at Kelsey Goss but are offended by "shutup?" Printing out Colin Drafts' girlfriend is funny but "Shutup Coach" is offensive? I don't get it. I really, honestly, do not understand where the line is. Like I said earlier, when Barber asked us not to say "suck" I obeyed (or made a conscious effort to). If they can legitimately tell me what's ok and what isn't, while I may not agree with it, I'll figure out ways around it. I just can't understand for the life of me how shutup is offensive.
By DutchyNY
Registration Days Posts
#125223
thats funny seein as how if ergun caner says shut up or that something is gay or it sucks in convo everyone is high-fiving in the aisles because its cool to be edgy...
ill never understand what gets into people at LU where they think it is at all acceptable to try and scold eachother in public either....some sort of self righteous power trip that comes over people spending too much time on that mountain iguess
i have found it is easiest to just appease the sensitive ones until the larger crowds arrive then go to town
heck i booed danny gathings when he returned larry blair his mvp trophy in convo
User avatar
By PAmedic
Registration Days Posts
#125224
this is the most bizarre situation I've ever heard.

The AD really needs to get a handle on it, and SOON.

Why do I have the feeling it will be an item of discussion w/ KK first thing tomorrow? 8)

go get 'em, Kev!
By rogers3
Registration Days Posts
#125227
Hmmm- Ron Godwin moralizing????
By SuperJon
Registration Days Posts
#125228
I admit, in front of God and the entire internet, that at one point tonight I lost my cool and was wrong for what I said. I just don't understand some of this and it really confuses me. I try to be polite to those in authority and respect their wishes but we're being told two different things. I have no doubt in my mind that it'll get settled, and I honestly believe JB, MG, and KK will pull for the students as hard as possible, but until that time, I just don't know what can be said and what can't be.
By thepostman
#125233
rogers3 wrote:Hmmm- Ron Godwin moralizing????
my thoughts exactly....

with that said...I think this issue will be handled...I did e-mail JB during the weekend about some of these same issues SJ, and his response led me to believe that he is aware of these issues and has every intention in talking to the ones in charge the need to be talked about.
By SuperJon
Registration Days Posts
#125236
I have no doubt it will be taken care of as I said earlier. I just wanted to know what people truly thought was acceptable or unacceptable because I honestly do not know. I'm so confused about it it isn't even funny. I'm normally the one telling people to chill out or to tone down what they're saying.
User avatar
By DeathCab4LU
Registration Days Posts
#125238
I went to a huge state school before I transfered to LU and I have heard alot of things yelled at coaches....lol I was impressed with LU because there fans could be in a competitive Christian atmosphere and could talk "smack" but in a respectful way and do not understand how shut up is in anyway offensive at all. On another note I want to say that it was an ok turn out for an exhibition game but I was disappointed that the students didn't stand up or get in the game at all.
By SuperJon
Registration Days Posts
#125239
I agree with that post completely, on every point.

I cannot stress enough how confused I am about this whole stuff.
User avatar
By DeathCab4LU
Registration Days Posts
#125242
I really can't wait for this to all get figured out
By thepostman
#125244
the thing is SJ I am not sure if it will ever be truly resolved...some people are just so uptight about things and you just are never going to please everybody. I think the fact that you went about things the way you did and even admitted you were wrong in your initial reaction will go a long way in this...

I know for me personally, hearing somebody say shut up and sit down isn't offensive, or for that matter saying somebody sucks...and i have never been very good at putting myself and somebody else's shoes....

its a hard issue to define, and thought it may get better once brought into the open, it will never be completely solved because everybody has different opinions on what is appropriate for Christians to do..
User avatar
By Cider Jim
Registration Days Posts
#125246
Super, speaking as a fan and not as a prof, I'm not sure where the line is drawn either. But as you say, it's largely a generational thing, because for a college student to tell anyone over 40 to "shut up" would be offensive to anyone who is 40-something or older. The same would go for the word "suck" (for the 40+ crowd).

Yet, we often will use the line "Sit down!" when referring to an opposing coach who is standing and arguing with a ref.

Just be careful, Super, because the last thing in the world that I want to see is you getting carried away in handcuffs by the LUPD in the middle of a game. We need you and your support on the students' side of the Vines.
By SuperJon
Registration Days Posts
#125248
That's why I went and found Barber and asked him. I'd NEVER heard that before and wanted to know for sure. I don't want to get kicked out of anything. I'm not saying I'm right in this issue by any means, but I just have no clue what's going on.
By TDDance234
Registration Days Posts
#125249
Ultimately, if LUPD said not to say it--the general rule is not to say it. I know that goes against what most people think here at Liberty but they do have authority and if they said it's something by Dr. Godwin and Co. than it should be respected?

Does that mean we agree? No... but we do respect it.
By SuperJon
Registration Days Posts
#125250
TDDance234 wrote:Ultimately, if LUPD said not to say it--the general rule is not to say it. I know that goes against what most people think here at Liberty but they do have authority and if they said it's something by Dr. Godwin and Co. than it should be respected?
If it's general university stuff, I will listen to them. However, if it's athletics, I do what Jeff Barber says. He's the highest authority in terms of athletics and the only person I would listen to over him in that situation is Jerry Jr. Athletic events are Jeff Barber's territory. That's what Doc hired him to do.
By TDDance234
Registration Days Posts
#125252
Dr. Godwin still has a big part in running this university. Athletics are a part of this university and Jeff Barber works for the university.

While I agree with you that it's stupid and not worth making a fuss about, they have jurisdiction and the authority to make those calls.
By SuperJon
Registration Days Posts
#125254
They might, but I went to Jeff Barber, the Director of Athletics, and was told I was ok. Dr. Godwin may be a part of running the University, however, until someone with more authority than you tells me so, he is not a higher voice than Jeff Barber in terms of athletic events.
Chadwell’s Health

Fair point. None of us are on the inside, but comm[…]

Sam Houston 1/10 3:30 EST

We did not play particularly well and Sammy shot m[…]

25/26 Season

Nobody knows 747s better!

Transfer Portal Reaction

That’s fair, and no one’s dismissing h[…]