LUconn wrote: It would be who impressed me more face to face.
Which of course is why all of our opinions are totally meaningless speculation unless we have actually met one or more of the candidates in more than just a casual encounter. Don't get me wrong, I'm participating and enjoying the discussion, but I confess that all any of these candidates are to me is a head shot from their SID's office and a bunch of numbers and names saying where they worked, with whom, how long and how many games they won and lost.
JB has worked with at least 4 of them (including Zack and Alexis), and will be interviewing others and getting references from people he trusts who know them and their work well.
I keep thinking about my beloved Pittsburgh Steelers as they were looking for a replacement for semi-legendary Bill Cowher. They bring in this young defensive coordinator from Minnesota Mike Tomlin for an interview primarily to fulfill the "Rooney Rule" which requires a minority be interviewed for openings. He blows them away in the interview, and he is now their head coach.
I'm having a blast speculating here on flamefans, but at this point I'm ready to accept whoever JB chooses and support him 100%, simply because it's his decision to make, all indications are he has gone about the search in a thorough and professional manner, and as far as I'm concerned he hasn't given us any reason to doubt his judgement yet.