rtb72 wrote:Jonathan Carone wrote:1) Where the ball goes on a 4th down play on your own 14 yard line should be the responsibility of the highly compensated coaching staff who is paid to make those decisions.
2) Those same coaches have recruited and coached the quarterback and should know his game management and football intellect limits.
That terrible decision falls completely on the coaching staff no matter how much they want to throw the player under the bus.
THIS! So TG left it up to the QB for a 4th down and inches on your own 14? Then, makes it clear whose call it was. This bothers me. Take some d^&% ownership of your place as a leader! Stop with the "it's so and so's fault! Winning season or not...this seems to happen to much and is not the mark of an effective leader.
Want to offer a different perspective. One has to go back to the root cause of the problem. As much as i would like to, I don't see TG blaming this on the QB. The play was called to be an option, based on how the defense lined up, not on what Calvert thought was the best way to execute ie. pass or run. I do not believe TG is trying to throw Buckshot under the bus and blame him for passing the ball.
HOWEVER, the root cause of the problem is that there never should have been any call made, except to punt the ball. TG made the decision not to, which as stated earlier, I believe to be the dumbest call I have ever seen in watching/playing football for more than 55 years. TG is responsible 100% for the eventual outcome.
What was the biggest play of the game, the one that turned the tide and completely changed the momentum of the game? Going for it on 4th and inches, early in the 3rd quarter, deep in your own territory, down only 7 points? This is just a great example of why he is not qualified to coach at the FBS level and will never be the person that is capable of taking LU where we all want to see it go.
This decision, in addition to playing hurry-up football late in the 4th quarter against Troy, with the lead BTW, should leave the subjective observer no doubt that his decision-making ability is deeply flawed.
I hope the university can find a place for him to contribute, far, far away from the football field. He is a good man, just can't coach.