- March 11th, 2013, 2:59 pm
#423160
We were good under Royer.
We were good under Pastors.
To think that we never had talent or never had a chance to win or weren't good under those two coaches shows how absolutely little you know about our baseball program. We knocked on the door of regionals under those two coaches. We actually even made it to one then as well. Pastors even won a game in regionals. Royer had our team one game away from regionals his last two years. He had winning records his final three years including a then school record for wins in 06. Royer was limited by his coaching ability. We had talent. And we ran a clean program that represented our school well.
Here's the truth about Toman: The closest he came to getting to the regionals was in his first year with none of his own players. Sure, he can absolutely recruit with the best of them. However, he's a horrible representative of our school. He doesn't take care of his players. He has recruited players that had absolutely no place coming to Liberty. Thankfully, to his credit, after all of those kids left a few years ago he started recruiting kids that were much better fits at our school but it took years to improve their reputation on campus.
I'm willing to bet 3-4 guys will end up having to have Tommy John this year because of his inability to manage a pitching staff. I'm also not a fan of a coach who will pin a player up against the dugout and choke him during a game. Ask anyone who has had any dealing with Toman over the past five years. None of them like him. All of them think he's a joke. And many of them were recruited and/or played for him.
I'm not going to blindly follow a coach just because he can win 40 games. I would rather have a quality guy who represents our school well. He's upgraded the talent but he has yet to do anything that the two previous coaches did and they did it while representing the school in a better way. Why are we okay with down years in soccer every couple of years? It's because Jeff Alder is a great guy who is truly a Liberty guy. I'd rather have that than a guy who has no place at Liberty winning 40 games and never winning a conference championship or make it to the regionals.
If Toman has been one of the hottest up and coming coaches in the country over the past three years, why hasn't he gotten a sniff at a job better than us? Why has he only been in the running at crappy, bottom of the barrel schools and not quality ones? Why hasn't he been offered anywhere other than Maryland? People know he's not a good coach.
Great recruiter.
Terrible manager.
Talent wins a whole lot of games. In the past four years, we've lost 39 games by less than 3 runs. We've won 32 games by less than 3 runs. A good coach is 50/50 in games under 3 runs. A great coach is above 50/50. We've missed out on regionals by an average of two good wins over the past three years. Where were those two good wins each year? Lost in a game by under three runs.
Toman has done a nice job but he wasn't hired to do nice things. He was hired to take LU to the next step and we're still waiting on him to do something that other coaches have never done.