Purple Haize wrote: ↑May 16th, 2020, 2:31 pm
Ill flame wrote: ↑May 16th, 2020, 12:47 pm
tyndal23 wrote: ↑May 16th, 2020, 11:53 am
For sure. That is why I have argued to the “ just win” crowd that 4 P5 games is at least 2 too many. In my view - we won’t ever be invited to a conference based on our beliefs ( we very well could but that is a hope and out of our control ). We are independent - therefore we can be happy as a G5 type ( apparently the term equivalent is banned from some on this board ) and that will be the extent of it. Or we can take the hard road - which is doable but requires a firm commitment with a lot more up front $ invested. Anything we do as a G5 type will have zero impact if and when we decide to be a P5 type. So if the eventual goal is to actually be ND BYU - we are simply wasting time at the G5 type level. The process will be just as difficult 10 -30 years from now as it would be if we had taken that philosophy day1 or even 2026 ( 1st available opportunity schedule wise ).
Don't overlook what winning 8+ games every year could do to grow a fanbase. If we averaged 9 wins a year until 2030 what would this program look like? At a minimum teams won't see us as just another FCS school and we would probably be averaging 30,000+ fans a game. BYU became the school they are today dominating the WAC so it can be done with weak schedules albeit over many years.
BYU also has a national championship. BYU also isn’t seem as a vagabond football program. They could have accepted invites to some conferences in the past but declined and they’ve also been the victim of Fat a few times
ND is a whole other category unto itself and LU loses any credibility in trying to say they are like ND.
Winning games against P5’s won’t make it easier to get games against P5 schools it will make it more difficult. Just saying that LU is now on Par with the P5’s of the World doesn’t make it true either.
BYU won the only one by non power conference in the AP era with a rude schedule that is still controversial - so that path or model is out for LU but the great thing for BYU is overall perception was etched and continues to this day. I don’t care how many good teams they had prior - it was the NC that bought them big boy prestige. They couldn’t get over the hump again and have gone Indie and figured out 4 P5 games weren’t doing them any favors either and have just started scheduling like a big boy. ( and yes their story is a bit more complicated but that sums up the big picture )
Who claims we are ND ? That is/was the goal laid out by Sr.
Winning P5 games as a G5 absolutely makes it more difficult to schedule them. UCF is a better team/program right now than BYU but P5 teams would rather schedule BYU home and home because they are perceived as P5 which is the entire premise of my argument of going all in, playing 5 home games and buying home games with Vandy,Kansas,Indiana types - it is the ONLY way To break out of the G5 level for LU. getting really good as a G5 makes it actually tougher.