This is the location for conversations that don't fall anywhere else on FlameFans. Whether its politics, culture, the latest techno stuff or just the best places to travel on the web ... this is your forum.

Moderators: jcmanson, Sly Fox, BuryYourDuke

#41939
LU debate coach to work with McCain committee

Ron Brown
rbrown@newsadvance.com
November 16, 2006


Brett O’Donnell, who guided Liberty University’s debate team to a consensus No. 1 national ranking earlier this year, is taking a leave of absence to become an adviser to presidential hopeful Sen. John McCain.

O’Donnell, who has coached LU’s debate team for 17 years, will serve as communications strategist for an exploratory committee assessing the viability of a McCain candidacy in 2008.

McCain, an Arizona Republi-can, on Thursday launched a presidential exploratory committee for a White House run. He has set up a campaign Web site at www.exploremccain.com.

O’Donnell is expected to start work with the campaign on Jan. 8.

“We’re very excited about that,” said John Weaver, McCain’s chief strategist. “We’re very fortunate to have him and his expertise and character with us. He has an innate ability to communicate and he certainly understands that role in a campaign.”

McCain, considered the frontrunner for the GOP nomination, was making several major speeches Thursday and was not available for comment, Weaver said.

The Rev. Jerry Falwell, LU’s co-founder and chancellor, said O’Donnell’s appointment is not necessarily a signal as to whom Falwell will support.

Falwell said he can back most of the prospective Republican candidates with the exception of former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani, who is pro-choice and pro-same-sex marriage.

Former Speaker of the House Newt Gingrich, Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney, Arkansas Gov. Mike Huckabee and U.S. Sens. Bill Frist (Tennessee) and Sam Brownback (Kansas) have all been listed as potential GOP candidates, among others.

“I want to support the candidate that opposes (Sen.) Hillary (Clinton),” Falwell said. “Most of our Republican candidates are going to be pro-life and pro-family. It is doubtful that I will get involved until much later.”

Support from conservative evangelical Christians was critical to the election of President Bush in 2000 and 2004.

McCain first approached O’Donnell in May when McCain was LU’s graduation speaker.

“The senator was part of the pitch,” O’Donnell said.

Mark McKennon, a media adviser to Bush, recommended O’Donnell to McCain and his staff.

“He thought the work I did for the president was very good,” O’Donnell said.

O’Donnell helped prep President Bush for his debates with Democratic candidate Sen. John Kerry during the 2004 campaign.

Bush ultimately was re-elected president.

O’Donnell said he will play an even greater role in the McCain campaign.

He will advise McCain on media interviews, help shape policy statements and prepare the senator for candidate forums and debates.

While he will work with McCain for the next year or two, O’Donnell is not severing LU ties.

“I’m taking a temporary leave of absence,” he said. “This was an extremely difficult decision for me. Being the director of debate at Liberty has been a special opportunity for me. Through the hard work of lots of students and coaches, we’ve built a nationally prominent debate program.”

Michael Hall, his assistant, will serve as the debate director in his absence.

“He was on the very first team I coached at Liberty,” O’Donnell said.

O’Donnell said regardless of the outcome of the McCain campaign, he would one day like to return to Liberty, where he did his undergraduate work.

“I credit Liberty with developing much of who I am as a person,” he said. “When I was a student at Liberty, I never dreamed I would have the opportunity to work with a president and another potential president.

“I relish the chance to give back to the university in any way I can.”

O’Donnell said Falwell didn’t set a time limit on how long his leave of absence could last.

“He basically said he would take me back whenever I decided to come back,” O’Donnell said. “He’s been very gracious in working with me with this opportunity.”

As LU’s director of debate, O’Donnell focused on providing students with skills in oral and written argument, critical thinking and persuasion.

His teams have won 18 national championships in intercollegiate debate over the last 13 seasons.

“No American university has been blessed with such a brilliant debate coach as Brett O’Donnell,” Falwell said. “Eighteen national championships speak for themselves. This has never happened before anywhere. My prayers go with him.”
http://www.newsadvance.com/servlet/Sate ... 6213&path=
User avatar
By bigsmooth
Registration Days Posts
#41956
i hate to see this, but im sure a good move for o'donnell. i hope he will return.
User avatar
By qkslvrsrfrboy
Registration Days Posts
#41984
brett is hoping to return, but mike is a great guy and really already has been the main coach, true that Brett is the head of the program, but mike is more the coacher. And were already in place to repeat last year only by an even bigger margin. Plus Brett is just 3 hours away and will still be visiting haha
By ATrain
Registration Days Posts
#42006
I've known about this, for-oh say, a little over a month now...unfortunately this is one of the few stories any Champion writer has ever had inside access to...too bad we couldn't break it back when we found out...grrr private institution rights concerning freedom of the press
User avatar
By Purple Haize
Registration Days Posts
#42107
All I have to say is:

RUDY RUDY RUDY RUDY RUDY RUDY!!! :D
User avatar
By TallyW
Registration Days Posts
#42118
I'm still a Condi fan. Although this certainly won't hurt McCain with the Conservative Christian crowd... Odonell will certainly be able to help him spin everything with the religious right. He may all of a sudden become more appealing with that crowd over the next year.

Also you can basically forget Odonell coming back. If McCain makes a good run (or wins) LU won't be able to afford Mr. Odonell.
User avatar
By PeterParker
Registration Days Posts
#42128
Or just happenstance? Seems like MWC is making a play for some serious points this season.


Source: http://www.umw.edu/universityrelations/ ... first1.php
UMW DEBATE TEAM WINS FIRST PLACE IN TWO NATIONAL TOURNAMENTS
Fredericksburg, Va. – The University of Mary Washington Debate Team finished first place this October at two national tournaments in which students debated the topic of Supreme Court jurisprudence. This broad topic included issues of abortion, school desegregation and executive authority in the war on terrorism.

Senior Scott Berry of Canton, Conn., and junior Nick Ryan of Iowa City, Iowa, defeated Boston College to claim first place at the J. Weinberg Memorial Debate Tournament held at the University of Richmond, October 14-16. The tandem also defeated teams from Liberty University, the University of Kentucky, James Madison University and the University of West Georgia on their way to the tournament championship.

Junior Cassandra Carlton of Stafford, Va., and freshman Amanda Gardner of Chesterfield, Va., defeated Liberty University in the final debate of the Capitol Cities Debate Tournament held at Catholic University, October 20-22. The UMW team also defeated Cornell University, Georgetown University, the Naval Academy and the U.S. Military Academy earlier in the tournament.

“The victory over Liberty University is especially significant because many, including the New York Times, consider them the number one debate team in the country,” said Tim O’Donnell, director of debate at UMW.
User avatar
By 01LUGrad
Registration Days Posts
#42194
2008 prediction...

The Republicans will need a "change" guy up front or they are toast. McCain has already positioned himself as that guy this week by his comments in committee.

Who for VP? Condi is an interesting pick, but I'm not sure the Republicans are going to want any Bush baggage heading into the next election. On the other hand, it would be great to see the GOP put forward the first woman/minority for the VP spot.

If Hillary gets the nomination, the Dems are stupid and I could beat her (if I was 35...age over beauty!).
User avatar
By whmatthews
Registration Days Posts
#42426
Liberty is only so good is because we have many teams we send out to get as many points as we can. We tend to look at debate like it's a sport because of a point system. Falwell always boasts about how we're better than Harvard, etc... but more than likely we probably haven't even debated them. We win because have more teams than everyone else, not because we're superior debaters.
User avatar
By whmatthews
Registration Days Posts
#42427
I think Condi would be a good choice for VP. Ofcourse democrats would point out the fact that she is baggage left from the Bush Administration, but Republicans can always use her to garner some of the African-American vote and maybe take hold of that vote, since most black voters vote Democrat but are not voting their conscious because as church-going people they aren't voting their values. The Democrats have done a great job in getting that vote, although in a very unethical way most of the time, but it's crucial because they generally aren't voting their values. Plus she's just about the only cabinet member for Bush that hasn't resigned.
User avatar
By qkslvrsrfrboy
Registration Days Posts
#42444
actually thats not why we win. we have debated harvard before, we debate them numerous times a year, sometimes we win, sometimes we lose. True we do send alot of teams (by alot though, all we send is 2 varsity, maybe 4 or 5 JV and 5 novices, thats the most we can send since thats all we have the numbers to send) everyone always says the only reason we win is because we send out alot of teams, however that is complete bull crap, i mean take a look at cornell, binghamton, University of Kansas, even Mary Washington, and just about everyother debate program, they all do the same thing, yet we still are winning. I mean at west point we had 4 novice teams and cornell had 10, its just that we had 4 novice teams clear to elimination and cornell didnt, because we actually beat them. Everyone says thats the only reason we win but its not. And if you speak to Brett or hear him talk about this, he is very excited about this opportunity but he still does and always will love liberty, i have no doubt in my mind he will come back someday.
User avatar
By whmatthews
Registration Days Posts
#42445
I'm going off of what Dr. Kramer tells us in debate class, he started the program at Liberty.
User avatar
By qkslvrsrfrboy
Registration Days Posts
#42446
alright well im going off of actually being on the team and knowing this from first hand experience
User avatar
By PeterParker
Registration Days Posts
#42450
I'm still curious if there is a relation between the two coaches from LU and MWC.
User avatar
By qkslvrsrfrboy
Registration Days Posts
#42545
also for those that may say that we really on our novice and JV teams to get points, if you look at just varsity teams, we are still in fourth, and harvard is still in the 20's somewhere.
By SuperJon
Registration Days Posts
#42546
Could you be more defensive?
User avatar
By TallyW
Registration Days Posts
#42608
lol... especially for a guy who's only been on campus for a few months :)

qkslvrsrfrboy... It's not like you're a 4 year letter winner... you've been here since August... relax... people have views and being around/on the team doesn't make everything you say right about the scoring system. You should know that. Present facts and let it go...
User avatar
By qkslvrsrfrboy
Registration Days Posts
#42688
sorry, its kinda just i dont know much about the football team and basketball teams, and this is what i talk about. plus every other debate team always gives us crap for it so we all get defensive because we really do earn the rankings. and true, i have only been at liberty a few months, but in the words of the debate coaches, as soon as you put points on the rankings, you can talk all you want
User avatar
By PeterParker
Registration Days Posts
#42714
That's good though, I'm sure the more "crap" those teams give you guys, the more you want to prove the rankings as valid by notching varsity wins. The more Varsity teams that continue to notch wins over those "established elite schools" will continue to validate the superlatives that have been showered on your program. Good to see team members getting fired up about the team and competing though...
By SuperJon
Registration Days Posts
#42716
They talk crap at debate matches? That's just funny.
User avatar
By qkslvrsrfrboy
Registration Days Posts
#42718
yeah, the entire debate is full of crap, i get what ur saying. But seriously other teams hate us and talk constant trash to us, cornell is the worst
User avatar
By PeterParker
Registration Days Posts
#42722
What exactly does elitist debate trashtalking sound like?
User avatar
By PAmedic
Registration Days Posts
#42724
and why do I have this visual of all these blonde guys named Brett with feathered hair, pastel Izod shirts (collars popped, of course) over Argyle sweaters, finished off w/ dockers and penny loafers- sneering at other guys that look identical to them.
User avatar
By PAmedic
Registration Days Posts
#42725
forgot about the mesh-weave belt.

actually still have one of those. MrsPA won't let me leave the house with it on though
Defensive Woes

The defense has been an issue since Day 1. HCJC is[…]

Jax State Thread

Missed FG again! This is getting hard to watch!

2025 off season

2025-26 full schedule is out. https://www.aseao[…]

Fall Schedule

Thank you for the info. Hopefully, they stay commi[…]