[TIMSCAR20]

How can they make us watch? I hope that isn't true. I am re-watching it on TIVO now too. Love that TIVO...Love that Elliott too.

[A.G.]

I'm all shook up!

McPhee must go. If for no other reason than that 2nd outfit. The gal has KANKLES!!!! Uggggh

[Jasmen8182]

Never voted for American Idol-haven't watched in a while-but found myself voting for American Inventor. It was a tough choice but my guy came in second. My son voted for the guy with the football training "catch".

[Hold My Own]

well, my guy from day 1 wins again....last year I nailed it during the auditions! not to mention I picked the American Inventor too!!!


MAN I'M GOOD!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[givemethemic]

NO you just don't have a life!!!!!!! J/K you know I love you like Brokeback does!!!!

[Hold My Own]

Just don't apologize the same he he apologizes to me....he then has to call me the next day to apologize again

[A.G.]

You really had to appreciate Kats "little black dress" last night, though. Her Mom is getting it done, too.

[TIMSCAR20]

I didn't pick Taylor but I did pick Carrie Underwood from her audition tape. She was fabulous (and the singing wasn't bad either!). I am happy that Taylor won instead of Katherine although obviously they both will do well. I think Katherine will do more acting than singing. I also think we will see Ace in a sitcom or something real soon about his life growing up in a big family of all boys. I didn't say it would be a good sitcom but there will be one developed I think.

[Hold My Own]

You really had to appreciate Kats "little black dress" last night, though. Her Mom is getting it done, too.

Yeah, I said something about that little black dress and I said I wonder if her mother would let her wear that out of the house....then the camera went to her mother

you ever hear that song "See get it from her mama!"

they both were trying to look like Paula has all year, and in FHM

[givemethemic]

That was a good song where she get that......"She get it from her mama" now I got that song in my head thanks HMO!!!!!!!!

[cheerbren]

I am so glad Taylor won!!! He is so fun to watch! As for Kat's dress I have on daughter who hated it and one who loved it(scary). My daughters or myself will not be allowed out of the house without our "girls" fully covered!!!

[A.G.]

Kat and her Mom in FHM??

mmmmmmmmmm. DONUTS!!!!!

(wait a minute, that would be a serious Liberty Way violation)

[Hold My Own]

no no....Paula

[A.G.]

The drool is over the THOUGHT of Kat and her Mom in FHM. I knew what you meant.

[Rocketfan]

But is it Me or does Toni Braxton not age at all(wow). I think Kat knew she was going to lose but wanted to make sure to leave all her cards on the table for future promotions lol.

Of all of them though, i think Daughtry has got the most appeal and will sell the most albums and he may be the only one we still remember a year from now.

[Hold My Own]

no kidding about toni....was that a teddy she was in????

How about her trying to grind on Taylor and he wouldn't have anything to do with it....that was a classic, i rewound that about 10 times to see that...

[LUconn]

you guys seriously need to find a woman (1 each). and then marry her. and then enjoy all of the privelidges that come with that territory.

[Flamesfanva]

Maybe Rhondetta will make it next year

[Brokeback Flamer]

you guys seriously need to find a woman (1 each). and then marry her. and then enjoy all of the privelidges that come with that territory.

What do you mean? Does that mean I have to move to Hawaii or Mass? I am just glad the gay guy won!

[A.G.]

The gay guy finished SECOND---two years ago. I am sure that his appearance was the highlight for Brokeback--in fact, perhaps it WAS Brokeback that appeared with him--or was he one of the singing cowboys--and was that SCAR with them, too?? Questions. So many questions?

BTW, I plan on moving to UTAH so I can have more than one woman.

[Rocketfan]

I am married, but i am just appreciating an attractive women, but at the same time saying both went a bit overboard in there own way to get noticed.

[Brokeback Flamer]

The gay guy finished SECOND---two years ago. I am sure that his appearance was the highlight for Brokeback--in fact, perhaps it WAS Brokeback that appeared with him--or was he one of the singing cowboys--and was that SCAR with them, too?? Questions. So many questions?

BTW, I plan on moving to UTAH so I can have more than one woman.

Are you trying to tell me this guy isn't gay? Get your gaydar checked LOL

[A.G.]

Are tyring to say Taylor snuck by us through the back door? NO WAY, hose-way.

[Brokeback Flamer]

Are tyring to say Taylor snuck by us through the back door? NO WAY, hose-way.

Are you allowed to say back door on this board?

[TIMSCAR20]

AG you think the Cowboy looks like me? Which one, the tall white guy, the little guy from the lolly pop guild or the brotha? I don't know what I would look like in a cowboy hat and I will never find out unless my converted Texas friend Sly Fox talks me into it. You may see me in a PAMedic t-shirt before that! Taylor is gay? I don't think so but I could be wrong. Mrs SCAR loves Katherine McPhee which is good because I can talk about her without fear of incurring her wrath. You married guys know what I am talking about.