bbrothers224 wrote:You're right. The Hendrix - Keaggy thing never happened...but the fact that an urban legend like that has continued to this day is testament to Keaggy's chops. Do a youtube search for Glass Harp and you can find a 20 something Keaggy and the rest of GH playing for a PBS show. True greatness. All guitar players know who Keaggys rep, but I've always wondered on the what if scenarios. You know... what if Keaggy had done what Bono, Edge and Larry did in U2? That it was ok to play in a rock n roll band period. To quote Martin Luther, "Why should the Devil have all the good tunes?" Just thinking. I myself...prefer the music by Christians in the general marketplace.
Hendrix/Keaggy was indeed an urban legend.
So, who was/is the greatest guitar player ever? The question is highly subjective, and although Hendrix often wins this disctinction by default, there are many who would regard Hendrix as merely the most hyped and dare I say over-rated guitarist ever. I would go as far as to say that Jimmy Hendrix wasn't even the best gutarist at Woodstock. I would give that honor to Carlos Santana, hands down. I'll give Hendrix this though, he may be the greatest "hard rock" or more specifically "psychedelic guitarist" ever. However, the better guitarists, historically play some kind of jazz/rock fusion and are rarely known on the pop scene.
The fact remains that Keaggy is at least as good as anyone, if not better. There are few if any that can pull off the type of acoustic show that he performs, which is much more difficult than electric. Keaggy's jazz-fusion version of "time" and his extended accoustic version of "rejoice" are as good as anything that I've ever heard live. And his performances have certainly surpassed anything that I've seen personally from Stanley Jordan to Steve Morse. Keaggy tops them all as far as I'm concerned.