NotAJerry wrote:ALUmnus wrote:
Sure, I think a Catholic could be saved, no doubt. But you have to question why they would be in a church whose official position is antithetical to Scripture. It doesn't make sense if they were really honest about it. What does it really matter if a church is conservative if they're teaching a false gospel?
Why are there Baptists who are in churches whose official position is antithetical to Scripture? Or Presbyterians? Or Pentecostals? It's because everyone has blind spots and every church is made up of fallen people so they are inherently, at some point, believing or doing something antithetical to Scripture. To say that someone can't be humble because they hold a position of leadership in any of them is ridiculous.
Do these denominations have a world-wide church with one central figure of authority who is bound to an official position that is antithetical to Scripture? No. It's called "Catholic (big C)" for a reason. To compare the two just doesn't fit.
Again, let's go back to a few of the things the RCC goes wholly against Scripture on: the gospel, grace, salvation, authority of the triune God, and authority of Scripture. THESE ARE NOT SECONDARY ISSUES. If you get these wrong, how is that in any way Christian? One of the RCC's official positions, taken with the same authority (actually with greater authority) than Scripture is that the church that you and I belong to are an anathema.
The Pope has cursed you. Admire that all you want, I won't.
Look, I'm just some Liberty-educated, unenlightened boob who will never convince you of anything. Instead, go read some nice Reformed folks who I know you probably admire. Read some of Carl Trueman's articles. Listen to John McArthur's series on the RCC. Listen to the podcast below from James White. They will all tell you the same thing.
http://www.aomin.org/aoblog/index.php?itemid=5401